Quick answer
COBRA is usually not cheaper than unsubsidized private insurance on premium alone, but it may be cheaper in total if switching plans would reset a deductible or disrupt expensive ongoing care. Marketplace private plans can be cheaper if Premium Tax Credits apply.
Calculate total costTry a quick COBRA vs Marketplace scenario
Move the sliders below to test how coverage months and expected medical bills can change the COBRA vs Marketplace decision.
COBRA vs private insurance comparison
| Question | COBRA | Private / Marketplace plan |
|---|---|---|
| Will my doctors change? | Usually no | Possibly yes |
| Can subsidies lower my premium? | No federal Marketplace subsidy for COBRA | Possible through Marketplace plans |
| Does deductible progress reset? | Usually no | Usually yes |
| Best use case | Short bridge with ongoing treatment | Lower monthly cost or long-term coverage |
When COBRA might actually be cheaper
COBRA may be cheaper in total if you have already spent thousands toward your out-of-pocket maximum and expect more medical care this year. The private plan premium may be lower, but a new deductible could increase your total cost.
When private insurance may be cheaper
Private Marketplace coverage may be cheaper if your household income qualifies for Premium Tax Credits, your preferred doctors are in-network, and you have little or no deductible progress to protect.
Official sources used
This educational guide links to official federal resources so readers can verify the COBRA and Marketplace rules before making coverage decisions.
Frequently asked questions
Is COBRA cheaper than private health insurance?
Sometimes, but not usually on monthly premium alone. COBRA may be cheaper in total if you already met your deductible or need expensive in-network care.
Is Marketplace private insurance?
Marketplace plans are private health insurance plans sold through HealthCare.gov or a state Marketplace, with possible income-based subsidies.
What should I compare first?
Compare total cost: premiums, deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, doctors, prescriptions, and remaining months in the year.